Dunn Lambert, LLC
We mean business
Comprehensive legal services for businesses in New Jersey and New York call 201-957-0874
Dunn Lambert, LLC
comprehensive legal services for businesses call 201-957-0874

Court dismisses breach of contract case

A judge recently dismissed a case filed in a Pennsylvania court saying New Jersey was a better venue for the suit. In the breach of contract suit, one man claims that he is owed profits from a New Jersey business.

In 2010, this man and another man signed an agreement which created the business. Each man had a 50 percent interest in the limited liability company. The man claims that it was this operating agreement that was breached. He says that he was wrongfully ousted from the company and is owed profits.

The other man -- the defendant in this case -- claims that the agreement was not breached. Instead, he argues that the man was only ousted after forging a business contract with a third party. Furthermore, he argues that under the terms of the operating agreement, the two men were allowed to compete with one another.

However, these merits were not heard by the judge in the case. Prior to hearing arguments about the contract dispute, the defendant claimed that this was not the proper venue for the case to be heard. The judge agreed. Despite the fact that both men live in Pennsylvania, the business was formed in New Jersey. Furthermore, much of its business took place in New Jersey. Therefore, the case was dismissed without prejudice.

If the man still wants his breach of contract case heard, he will need to refile the case in New Jersey. At that point, a New Jersey judge can determine if a breach occurred. This case shows how important it is to have the right help when handling a breach of contract claim. The courts have complicated rules which need to be followed for a case to even be heard.

Source: The Pennsylvania Record, "Phila. judge dismisses commerce action involving contractual dispute, says N.J. is better venue," Jon Campisi, Jan. 24, 2013

1 Comment

Very fascinating dispute, it's amazing to me how some states just don't want to deal with the drama if they know its another states drama. With larger businesses that are many states this happens all the time with the court system.

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Office Location

Dunn Lambert, LLC
East 80 Route 4 Suite 170
Paramus, NJ 07652

Paramus Law Office Map

Dunn Lambert, LLC
1745 Broadway, 17th Floor
New York, NY 10019
New York Law Office Map
Phone: 201-957-0874
Fax: 201-291-0140
Telephone: 212-768-0700
Fax: 212-519-9804
Best Lawyers | Best Law Firms | U.S.News & world report | 2016

GET ANSWERS from a firm
with a sense of business.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Review US
Subscribe to This Blog's Feed FindLaw Network